How to Screen Tenants in Massachusetts (Legally)

Reading Time: 4 minutes

How to Screen Tenants in Massachusetts (Legally) You can screen tenants in Massachusetts, but you have to do it by objective, consistent criteria and stay inside fair-housing law. You may check credit, income, rental history, and references. You may not reject applicants based on a protected class, and in Massachusetts that includes source of income,…

How to Screen Tenants in Massachusetts (Legally) - Green Ocean Property Management

How to Screen Tenants in Massachusetts (Legally)

You can screen tenants in Massachusetts, but you have to do it by objective, consistent criteria and stay inside fair-housing law. You may check credit, income, rental history, and references. You may not reject applicants based on a protected class, and in Massachusetts that includes source of income, so a Section 8 voucher is not a lawful reason to say no. You also generally cannot charge an application or screening fee.

The short answer

Legal screening comes down to two rules: judge every applicant by the same objective standards, and never use a protected characteristic as a factor. Write down your criteria before you advertise, apply them the same way to everyone, and document your reasons. Inconsistency is what turns a routine denial into a discrimination complaint. (Verified against the Massachusetts Commission Against Discrimination’s “Overview of Housing Discrimination” and Mass.gov’s security-deposit guidance, checked 2026-11-10.)

What you can legally ask

You can evaluate the things that actually predict a successful tenancy: verifiable income (a common benchmark is income at a multiple of rent, applied equally), credit history, prior rental history and landlord references, and employment verification. You can require these from every applicant. The key is that the standard is the same for everyone and is applied to the application, not to the person.

What you cannot ask (fair housing)

Federal and Massachusetts law protect a broad set of classes, and Massachusetts (G.L. c. 151B) goes further than federal law. Protected characteristics include race, color, national origin, religion, sex, disability, familial status, age, marital status, sexual orientation, gender identity, genetic information, veteran or military status, and source of income (including housing vouchers), among others. You cannot base a decision on any of them, and you cannot ask questions designed to reveal them. Source of income specifically covers more than Section 8 — MCAD’s guidance names SSDI, RAFT, HomeBASE, and Rapid Re-Housing assistance too, not just housing vouchers. (Verified against MCAD’s “Overview of Housing Discrimination,” last updated July 29, 2024, checked 2026-11-10.)

A compliant screening process

Build a repeatable process: publish the same objective criteria to everyone, use one standard application, get written consent before running credit or background checks, evaluate each applicant against the written criteria, and keep records of what you decided and why. Consistency plus documentation is your best protection if a decision is ever questioned.

The application-fee rule in MA

This one surprises out-of-state landlords. Massachusetts strictly limits what you can charge a tenant at move-in, generally first month’s rent, last month’s rent, a security deposit up to one month, and the cost of a new lock and key. Application fees and screening fees are generally not among the allowed charges. Do not charge an application fee assuming it is standard, it usually is not lawful here. (Verified against Mass.gov’s “Security deposits and last month’s rent” guidance, checked 2026-11-10: landlords may collect only first and last month’s rent, a security deposit up to one month’s rent, and lock/key costs.)

Red flags vs. protected categories

You are allowed to act on legitimate, documented concerns: insufficient verifiable income, a poor payment history, prior evictions for cause, or falsified application information, applied consistently. You are not allowed to dress up a protected-class decision as a “red flag.” The test is whether you would reach the same conclusion for any applicant with the same objective facts. If yes, you are on solid ground. If the real reason traces back to a protected characteristic, you are not.

Consumer reports and the adverse-action notice (FCRA)

If you run a credit check, a tenant-screening report, or a background check on an applicant, that report is a “consumer report” under the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), enforced by the FTC — and it comes with obligations on both ends.

If anything in that report plays any part — even a small part — in an unfavorable decision, you owe the applicant an “adverse action notice.” Adverse actions aren’t limited to a flat denial; requiring a co-signer, requiring a larger deposit than you’d ask of another applicant, or charging more rent than you’d charge another applicant all count. The notice must name the consumer reporting agency that supplied the report (its name, address, and phone number), state that the agency did not make the decision and cannot explain the specific reasons for it, and tell the applicant they can dispute the report’s accuracy and get a free copy of it if they ask within 60 days. The notice can be given in writing, electronically, or orally, but a written notice is the safer practice because it proves compliance. (Verified against the FTC’s “Using Consumer Reports: What Landlords Need to Know,” checked 2026-11-10.)

Screening is exactly the kind of compliance a professional manager runs every day, with consistent criteria and clean documentation. See how Green Ocean manages rentals.

Frequently asked questions

Can a landlord run a credit check in MA?

Yes, with the applicant’s consent, as long as you apply the same credit standard to everyone. Note that you generally cannot pass the cost on as an application fee.

Can I charge an application fee in Massachusetts?

Generally no. Massachusetts limits move-in charges to first month, last month, a security deposit up to one month, and a lock-and-key charge. Application and screening fees are typically not allowed.

What questions are illegal to ask?

Anything that targets a protected class, such as questions about family status, disability, religion, national origin, sexual orientation, or source of income. Ask about the application criteria, not the person.

Can I reject a Section 8 applicant?

Not because they use a voucher. Source of income is a protected class in Massachusetts, so refusing an applicant solely because they hold a Section 8 voucher is unlawful. You still apply your other objective criteria equally.

Want screening done right, every time? Green Ocean screens Boston-area applicants with consistent, fair-housing-compliant criteria so landlords stay protected. Request a proposal or call 617-487-4868. This guide is general information, not legal advice.

Essential Tenant Screening Criteria for Property Managers

Posted in

A tenant screening criteria checklist for property managers—income, credit, rental history, background, and identity standards applied fairly.

Understanding Tenant Background Check Services for Property Management

Posted in

What tenant background check services include—credit, criminal, eviction, and identity checks—and how to use them in an FCRA-compliant way.

4.9 stars on 1,000+ Google reviews. Managing Boston property since 1977.

Stay updated with market trends and changes

Expert knowledge and advice to help make your life as a property owner easier.